86 Eighty-Six: Is San Magnolia Doomed?

It’s not looking good for San Magnolia. 

In the most recent episode of 86 Eighty-Six we see an unthinkable situation occur. San Magnolia’s outer defenses are breached; the Legion has made it inside. As the legion broke into their territory, stunned officers questioned what they were seeing.

How did it come to this point? 

The clear answer is the overwhelming force of Legion breaking into their homeland. San Magnolia is outgunned and outmanned. While no civilization is ever destined to survive, there were many problems in the culture of San Magnolia. It wouldn’t be a shame if it all collapsed. 

What kind of culture did San Magnolia have? 

The cultural problems of San Magnolia were evident from the very first episode. It was a very hypocritical culture. 

The propaganda of the war painted their society as cultured, advanced, even ideal, sending self-piloting mechs into battle so no lives were lost because of their superior technology. The lie of the propaganda is that the mechs were piloted. But through sophistry it was argued that even if lives were being lost, they were just Eighty-Sixers who aren’t considered human. So of course no one had died. 

Remember in the first season as Lena begged her Uncle to do something about the treatment of the Eighty-Six. She argued the principles on which the republic was founded demanded they be treated equally, even with respect. Her uncle was not ignorant to what was going on, fully aware of what Lena was saying. And instead of feeling any kind of remorse or guilt he blamed the treatment of the Eighty-Six on the will of the people. Meaning that without political impetus to the contrary the genocide of the Eighty-Six would continue. 

From the context clues we have gotten so far, the society was largely morally bankrupt.  Lena’s words reached no one, and changed no one’s mind. Good Riddance San Magnolia. 

Bonus Thoughts 

While San Magnolia was a morally bankrupt culture, their military culture was arguably worse. Tasked with defending San Magnolia to ensure its survival, the officers of the military were constantly partying.  No one in the upper echelons of command was taking the war seriously. 

What was the reason the command structure didn’t take the war seriously? 

There was an unchallenged assumption, or belief, that the war would end after a certain period of time. The Legion was set to shut down. It was believed that the Legion would not be able to operate due past it’s AI lifespan. The math had already been done, and there was no reason for them to want to believe otherwise. The legion would be gone, and the Eighty-Sixers would be dead. 

For the military and the political arm of the Republic, this was a win-win situation. 

As we learned from Lena and her experience with her original spearhead squadron, the Legion actually wouldn’t actually shut down. The legion had the ability to assimilate the recent dead of the eighty-sixers and keep its own war machine operating. 

Like a zombie horde, the Legion just keeps on going. The assumptions of San Magnolia’s leadership structure are completely wrong. No one ever tries to figure out the true nature of the Legion, because in their mind they have already won the war. No mindset is more poisonous in war to assume you have won a war without knowing everything there’s to know about your enemy. 

Was this doom foreseeable? Absolutely. 

The only question I have is did Lena even try to warn the military of the truth? We never see her actually share the information she has learned. Did she already lose faith in the military and didn’t share the truth? Did she share her information and get rejected? I wonder if she tried. I wouldn’t blame her if she didn’t. 

Comment below to share your thoughts and reactions! 

3 thoughts on “86 Eighty-Six: Is San Magnolia Doomed?

  1. While it’s not looking good for San Magnolia, I’m more concerned about those at the Giad Federacy because Kiriya just launched a long-range attack against Shin and co. The 86 will have to defeat this unit that they retreated from in the past because of its attack range, and it will not be easy because that unit will most certainly be reinforced well by Legion units who it can coordinate with. Only then can Shin and the 86 save Lena from impending doom.

    On whether Lena shared this with the military, I don’t think she did. With Shin gone, Lena has no proof that the Legion would launch a huge assault on the Republic. As we could tell from an earlier episode this cour, she had a small posse that believed that there’d be a large-scale invasion, and they were probably people who believed in treating the 86 as humans and probably the only people in the know. If 86 was a really bold series, Lena could die, but I’m almost certain that she’ll live because she is Shin’s light and the only one that can make him feel something and look forward to the future.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I have read the LNs and I can say that lena did share her thoughts about the lasge scale attack but nobody believed. They think of her as young sympathiser of 86 so they never took her words into account. My memories are vague but I think her uncle might have believed her but didn’t do anything about it because he thought the republic deserved it.

    Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.